Nestled among fields in North Cape May, NJ, the new Nauti Spirits Distillery may have a few wrinkles to iron out, but is off to a pretty great start. We have visited 3 times so far, and found our experience improved with each stop. The experience really begins in the parking lot, as you find yourself looking at nicely painted, modern, warehouse-like buildings, located in the middle of some farmland. Horses sometimes peak over the fence of a neighboring property, tall grasses blow in the wind, and herbs and spices that are used in the cocktails are grown in boxes right in the lot. Entering takes you along a short, self-guided tour, providing insight into the processes required to make their vodka. Upon reaching the bar area one is immediately impressed by the design mixing modern, rustic and industrial flourishes. It feels like a cool place to be and one you would want to visit again.
As for the vodka itself, on all 3 of our visits I ordered it with club soda (and on one visit had a sip of it straight), and am very impressed. It is smooth and easy to drink, with almost no burn. Being made from sweet potatoes (which is not something I had seen before) gives it a pleasant sweetness as well. It's not overpowering, but it's just there enough to make the vodka that much more interesting and enjoyable on its own. At $30 a bottle in the gift shop, it's well worth the price.
Our experience however has been a little uneven. Our 1st trip was before their official grand opening, and it was more than a little disappointing. The young man who took care of us seemed very confused about nearly everything, put way too much bitters into one of our drinks, and overcharged us for the aforementioned vodka and club. It was good, but $11 for such a simple drink is a bit on the absurd side. We chalked it up to opening week mistakes and figured we would give it another try after things had settled down. It's a good thing we went back as the subsequent visits have been much better. On visit #2, they had a special Strawberry Rhubarb cocktail that Patrick and one of our friends visiting from Massachusetts could not stop raving about, and the price of my preferred vodka and club had come down to a much more reasonable $9. Another of our friends had a drink with bitters in it and received a better ratio to other ingredients of that as well. Visit #3 was equally pleasant, and my drink had come down further to $8, which seems about appropriate. The bartenders on 2nd and 3rd visits were also much more knowledgeable and invested in the product. Lastly, and I know some people are going to disagree with me on this, but I find their practice of crushing the ice for drinks with a mallet in a small burlap bag to be a bit much, and something that should probably be discontinued. It is moderately impressive the first time, but after that it seems like it makes the process of getting ice both too loud and too time-consuming. You can feel free to disagree with me on that though.
All in all, they have managed to win us over. It's a great product, in a great location, and one you should definitely try to visit when you find yourself in the Cape May area.